Disclaimer: This is an illustrative example based on a typical claim scenario. It does not represent a specific real client. Individual outcomes vary. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
Background
This representative case involves a former Royal Navy marine engineering mechanic who served for 15 years aboard various warships and auxiliaries. His primary working environment was the ship's engine room, where he was responsible for the operation and maintenance of propulsion systems, generators, and auxiliary machinery.
What Was the Noise Exposure?
Ship engine rooms produce continuous noise levels of 100–120 decibels. The engineer worked regular watches in the engine room, typically 6–8 hours at a time. In his earlier years of service, hearing protection provision was inconsistent. When protection was provided, it was often basic foam plugs that did not adequately attenuate the low-frequency engine noise that predominates in engine room environments.
What Were the Symptoms?
The veteran's primary complaint was severe, persistent tinnitus — a continuous low-pitched humming and buzzing in both ears that began during his final years of service and worsened after discharge. The tinnitus significantly affected his sleep, concentration, and mood. He also experienced mild hearing loss, but the tinnitus was the dominant condition. He reported that the sound was particularly distressing in quiet environments and at night.
How Was the Claim Handled?
The claim focused on the MOD's failure to provide adequate hearing protection for engine room work and failure to conduct adequate hearing surveillance that might have identified early signs of hearing damage. Medical evidence confirmed severe tinnitus consistent with prolonged engine room noise exposure. The impact on the veteran's daily life and mental health was a significant element of the claim.
What Was the Outcome?
The claim settled for £28,000, reflecting the severity of the tinnitus and its substantial impact on quality of life. The award was assessed within the moderate to severe tinnitus bracket of the JCG guidelines (£18,180 to £36,260), taking into account the associated sleep disturbance and psychological impact.
Related Resources
Case Summary
- Branch
- Royal Navy
- Condition
- Severe Tinnitus
- Settlement
- £28,000